Negotiators at COP31 have significantly pared back proposed guidance for the Paris Agreement’s Article 6.4 carbon market, removing several provisions on environmental integrity and economic viability while leaving contentious proposals on crediting methodologies and post-issuance authorisation unresolved, Carbon Pulse reports. For project developers and credit buyers, the rewrite of the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM) guidance cuts both ways: it could ease the regulatory friction that has slowed the mechanism, and it could weaken the safeguards on which demand for its credits ultimately depends.

What the latest text takes out

The latest PACM guidance text strips back integrity provisions and removes references to project costs and viability, Carbon Pulse reports. The deletions land in the middle of a week of argument over whether the mechanism’s rules are too strict to be workable. Some countries have pushed for weaker rules on the grounds that existing requirements were too stringent and threatened the mechanism’s economic viability, according to EnviroNews Nigeria.

Industry bodies had made that case in writing before the talks. IETA, the Project Developer Forum and the Wildlife Conservation Society called on COP31 delegates in an open letter to issue formal guidance to the Article 6.4 Supervisory Body to address slow project implementation, regulatory friction and looming financial constraints within the mechanism, Carbon Herald reports. The signatories warned that slow methodology development, complex conservative baselines and high uncertainty requirements threaten the mechanism’s uptake and long-term financial viability. They noted that the mechanism relies on credit issuance fees for self-funding and faces depleting reserve resources transferred from the Clean Development Mechanism Trust Fund, according to Carbon Herald.

Their letter listed five priority interventions for the CMA: an official impact assessment of standards, revised downward adjustment rules, broader participation for capacity-constrained nations, refined reversal risk frameworks and governance reform, Carbon Herald reports.

What stays unresolved

Two of the most contentious items remain open: proposals on crediting methodologies and on post-issuance authorisation, Carbon Pulse reports. Both sit at the core of how credits will be generated and how host countries will apply corresponding adjustments, so their deferral extends the uncertainty developers already face.

During the first week, the chairs of the informal consultations on the Supervisory Body report and Article 6.4 guidance asked Parties for written comments and proposals for a draft decision, and it was not immediately clear whether that session would resume the following day, IETA reports. The talks continue on Monday 16 November: the official programme lists an Article 6.4 mechanism guidance consultation from 10:00 to 11:00 in Meeting Room 06, followed by an Article 6.2 cooperative approaches consultation from 17:00 to 18:00, according to The Planet Brief.

The integrity camp pushes back

Climate and human rights organisations have warned against attempts by some countries to weaken the rules governing the Paris Agreement’s international carbon-crediting mechanism, and urged governments to reject any COP31 guidance that lowered existing standards or weakened protections for people, nature and the climate, EnviroNews Nigeria reports.

“As the world edges ever closer to breaching the 1.5°C temperature limit, any attempt by a State to weaken the rules of the Paris Agreement’s carbon market is utterly unacceptable,” said Erika Lennon, Senior Attorney at the Centre for International Environmental Law (CIEL), according to EnviroNews Nigeria. “Weakening the rules is not climate ambition. It is a license to pollute.” Elisa Morgera, the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and Climate Change, warned that lowering environmental standards for carbon credits would be counterproductive at a time when climate change is intensifying, EnviroNews Nigeria reports.

A market waiting for its rules

The credibility fight matters because Article 6 volumes are growing. The Article 6 Network, launched at COP31, calculated in its State of the Article 6 Market report that 53 million tonnes of carbon have been transacted by governments through the Article 6.2 and 6.4 mechanisms, and estimated that as many as 2.3 billion tonnes could be available by 2030, IETA reports.

The first week of the conference brought a stream of Article 6 announcements: Côte d’Ivoire and Sweden signed an Article 6.2 agreement, Norway and Indonesia signed a deal to trade millions of credits, and Uzbekistan transferred 7.78 million ITMOs from a methane project, according to IETA. On aviation, ICAO added four standards to CORSIA Phase 2, with PACM approved conditionally, IETA reports.

What buyers and developers should watch

First, the Monday consultations in Meeting Room 06. Whether Parties restore any of the removed integrity provisions in the next text will signal how much of the Supervisory Body’s framework survives political negotiation.

Second, the written comments requested by the chairs. They will show which governments pushed to delete the cost and viability references, and which want them back.

Third, the unresolved items. Until crediting methodologies and post-issuance authorisation are settled, developers cannot price regulatory risk, and buyers cannot be certain what a PACM credit will represent.