GS1247 VPA 67 Zoba Debub Community Boreholes

Audit Analysis

This Gold Standard water-borehole project in Eritrea displaces household fuel use and has a VVB-confirmed investment additionality test, but is undermined by a 0% leakage deduction that contradicts the 5% planned in the PDD, the absence of a buffer pool for physical infrastructure, and a large number of open corrective actions and material findings. Thirteen cross-document contradictions—including on FPIC status, additionality test type, and crediting period—further erode confidence in the data record, compounded by a low extraction confidence rating across 32 source documents.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Leakage deduction reduced from 5% (PDD, 2023) to 0% (verification report, 2024) with only a generic 'quantified' justification; no detailed leakage analysis is provided in the extracted record.
• ⚠Fifteen-plus material findings and corrective actions remain open, including undemonstrated sampling confidence (CAR#2), unmet 1 km distance requirement for some households (CAR#5), and an unclarified objective observer (CAR#4).
• ⚠FPIC status is contradictory: the 2018 verification report records it as not conducted, while the 2025 validation report records it as conducted; the basis for the change is not documented.
• ⚠Low extraction confidence across the 32 source documents means key quantitative fields may be unreliable.

Credit Vintages