Mabwepande Composting Facility for Market Waste

Audit Analysis

The Mabwepande composting project has VVB-confirmed additionality and a reasonable 0% leakage assumption for its sector, but is undermined by a large volume of material findings (17 items) and corrective actions (12 items) covering calculation errors, missing documentary evidence, and a two-year crediting-period shift. The verified emissions reduction of 4,509 tCO₂e represents only about 11% of the pro-rata expectation for the elapsed monitoring period, raising serious questions about the ex-ante estimate's realism. Multiple transparency and documentation gaps (no FNRB, no buffer pool, no FPIC, no CORSIA/CCP status) further weaken the project's credibility.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Verified ERR of 4,509 tCO₂e is only ~11% of the pro-rata expectation (~40,221 tCO₂e) for the 20-month monitoring period out of the 60-month crediting period, suggesting the ex-ante lifetime estimate of 120,662 tCO₂e may be substantially overstated
• ⚠17 material findings and 12 corrective actions in the verification report, including multiple calculation errors (CAR-1 to CAR-7), missing documentary evidence (CL-1 to CL-5), and a two-year shift in the crediting period start date
• ⚠Crediting period shifted from 2020-06-01 (PDD) to 2021-09-01 (monitoring report) without clear evidence that the baseline remains conservative (CAR-3)
• ⚠Safeguards documentation is contradictory: the 2023 verification report confirms safeguards and a grievance mechanism, but the 2020 monitoring report records safeguards as not mentioned

Credit Vintages Exhausted