Bare bones final guidance texts on Articles 6.2 and 6.4 at COP31 in Antalya mandate very little in the way of action for Paris carbon markets over the next year, Carbon Pulse reports, and observers and negotiators noted that the sour mood in the rooms and the failure to find consensus on straightforward issues point to challenges down the line. For buyers of internationally transferred mitigation outcomes and developers banking on the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM), the message from Antalya is that the machinery is idling while the disputes behind it harden.

What the guidance texts do, and do not do

Minimalist final guidance texts on Articles 6.2 and 6.4 mandate very little action for Paris carbon markets over the next year, Carbon Pulse reports. The Article 6 rulebook was completed at COP29 in Baku after almost a decade of negotiations, and Antalya was never expected to reopen it, the Florence School of Regulation notes. The question in Antalya was whether the architecture works in practice.

The formal review of the existing Article 6.2 guidance remains scheduled to resume in 2028, a timetable set after COP29 in Baku rather than a new postponement decided this week in Antalya, according to ClimateTrade.

A 2027 assessment, not a reopening

A near-final text leaves parties on course to request an assessment of the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism’s methodological work in 2027, with a formal opening of the standards currently off the table, Carbon Pulse reports. The text reflects a clear landing zone between those pushing for a relaxation of the rules and those defending the current framework, per Carbon Pulse.

The underlying split runs along familiar lines. Several developing country groups, Brazil, Norway and Indonesia want looser methodological standards while the EU defends the current ones, according to IETA, cited by ClearBlue Markets. Inside the Article 6.4 consultations, interventions asked the Supervisory Body to prioritise activities with a high level of readiness rather than mitigation potential, to consider large-scale removals methodologies, to avoid repeating work on methodologies, and to move its work beyond transitioned CDM methodologies, IETA reports.

Thin infrastructure, thin budgets

Behind the mood music sit concrete gaps. Of 106 parties analysed, 94 have developed or are preparing to develop authorisation and/or tracking arrangements, but only 15 currently have both authorisation and tracking arrangements fully in place, IETA reports. Authorisation, registry systems and environmental integrity were named as areas of disagreement in the talks, alongside technical expert review consistency, infrastructure and funding, per IETA.

The infrastructure that supports cooperative approaches under Article 6.2 and the PACM under Article 6.4 faces budget shortfalls, and parties must decide how to fund it on a stable basis, the Florence School of Regulation reports. A first version of the Article 6.2 International Registry, which countries without their own registry can use to record and track ITMOs, was demonstrated by the UNFCCC on 16 November, according to ClearBlue Markets. By 17 November, parties still differed on who should pay, ClearBlue Markets notes.

Why the mood matters for the market

The concern voiced in Antalya is less about any single paragraph than about trajectory. Observers and negotiators noted that the sour mood in the rooms, and the failure to find consensus on straightforward issues, suggest challenges down the line for Paris carbon markets, Carbon Pulse reports. When parties cannot agree on simple guidance questions, the harder fights over methodologies, funding and the 2028 review become harder still.

For buyers, the practical consequence is continuity rather than change: no new obligations, no reopened standards, and a demand signal that governments continue to build outside the negotiating rooms. On 12 November, 14 countries issued the Antalya Statement and launched a Policy Playbook with eight levers to grow corporate demand for high-integrity carbon credits, ClimateTrade reports.

What to watch next

Three dates now structure the Article 6 calendar. First, the 2027 assessment of the PACM’s methodological work, if the request is confirmed in the final text, which will test whether the landing zone found in Antalya holds. Second, the funding question for the Article 6.2 and 6.4 infrastructure, where parties must decide how to put the systems on a stable footing, per the Florence School of Regulation. Third, the formal review of Article 6.2 guidance, still scheduled to resume in 2028, ClimateTrade confirms. Each is a checkpoint where the disputes deferred in Antalya return with a deadline attached.