Additionality: the methodology itself gives it (U.S. Forest Protocol v5.1 §3.3, p. 20). The project needs no test of its own. CM-F-CAR-US-FOREST-ADDITIONALITY
CAR-US-FOREST — U.S. Forest Protocol
About this methodology
Forest carbon projects in the United States reforest land, improve forest management or avoid the conversion of forest. The protocol sets eligibility and accounting rules for the removals and reductions from these projects.
- Issued by
- Climate Action Reserve (CAR) · issuer's site
- Version
- 5.1 · source ·
- Status
- Active at Climate Action Reserve · source ·
- Climate outcome
- Emission reductions and CO2 removals
- Activity
- Forestry
- Official page
- climateactionreserve.org ·
- Also used by projects of
- American Carbon Registry (ACR) (2 projects)
How methodology v3 reads projects of this type
What CarbonMeld reads
- Integrity shown
- shown
Buffer pool: the methodology sets rules for it (U.S. Forest Protocol v5.1 §7, p. 87). CarbonMeld reads it in the project's documents. At the listing stage, the Reserve's Forest Project Submittal Form has no section on the buffer pool (Climate Action Reserve, «Forest Project Submittal Form», June 28, 2017). CarbonMeld then adds no buffer flag. CM-F-CAR-US-FOREST-BUFFER
Leakage not addressed (forest and land) Q-LEAKAGE-NOT-ADDRESSED
Forest, wetland, peat, grassland and soil carbon: the documents read do not address leakage. Outside REDD+ and reforestation, the rule applies only where the methodology requires a leakage assessment. At the listing stage, the rule does not apply if the programme's listing form has no section on leakage. CarbonMeld applies this rule only where a check of the documents has confirmed its condition; without that check, the rule takes no points.
Where carbon is stored: the permanence start P-START
CarbonMeld scores permanence only for projects that store carbon. Forest projects start from CCQI's grade of the programme on criterion 3.2. CCQI grades this criterion by programme, so its grade applies to every methodology of the programme. Where CCQI does not grade the programme, permanence starts at the neutral 5.0: the CDM's grade does not stand in for another programme's approach to permanence. Direct air capture with storage, biogenic emissions capture with storage, other geological storage and biochar start at the top, 8.0. The EU classes these types as permanent carbon removals. Enhanced weathering also starts at 8.0. It shares a family with direct air capture. This start is our own judgement. Concrete carbonation, ocean alkalinity, buried biomass and long-lived materials start at the neutral 5.0. These types have no class in a public source.
Forests: CCQI's grade of the programme.
Set by the methodology or the programme, not assessed by our current method
- not assessed
No legal requirement for the activity: the methodology sets rules for it (U.S. Forest Protocol v5.1 §3.3, p. 20). Our current method does not assess it. CM-F-CAR-US-FOREST-REGULATORY-SURPLUS
- not assessed
Our current method does not check how realistic the baseline scenario of the project is. An example is the harvest level that the project compares with. CM-F-CAR-US-FOREST-BASELINE-REALISM
Not applicable to this type — never a gap in our current method
The criterion does not apply to this methodology. Our current method never counts it as a gap.
- CM-N-GRID-EFGrid emission factor
- CM-N-FNRBFraction of non-renewable biomass (fNRB)
- CM-N-USAGEUsage rate of the devices
- CM-N-DURABILITY-MEASUREMENTDurability of the storage
- CM-N-FEEDSTOCK-SUSTAINABILITYSustainability of the feedstock
- CM-N-END-USE-TRACKINGTracking of the end use
The general rules apply as well. Read the general rules.
The rules of methodology v2.2, as they were: the archived v2.2 page.
History and transitions
All 9 versions · current v5.1
-
v5.1currentsource
The Reserve reincorporated reforestation as a project type in the U.S. Forest Protocol (FP); integration of a previously issued erratum to version 5.0; the scope of the update was limited to program revisions that are editorial or technical in nature
-
v5.016 Oct 2019 (the issuer's date)source
The revision from U.S. Forest Protocol Version 4.0 to 5.0 involved the addition of a standardized baseline option; a revised minimum verification schedule, inclusion of the Quantification Guidance as an appendix
-
v4.028 Jun 2017 (the issuer's date)source
The revision from U.S. Forest Protocol Version 3.3 to 4.0 involved eligible location expansion to Hawaii and U.S. territories; a new public lands baseline methodology for improved forest management projects; replacement of the Logical Management Unit approach with project area requirements
-
v3.315 Nov 2012 (the issuer's date)source
The revision from U.S. Forest Protocol Version 3.2 to 3.3 involved minor editorial changes and clarifications; improved guidance based on recommendations from the soil carbon, lying dead wood, and sustainable forestry certification
-
v3.231 Aug 2010 (the issuer's date)source
Minor editorial changes and clarifications; improved guidance for baseline determination (improved forest management projects); incorporated the forest verification protocol; corrected calculation methods for leakage and harvested wood products
-
v3.122 Oct 2009 (the issuer's date)source
The U.S. Forest Protocol revision from Version 3.0 to 3.1 involved minor editorial changes and clarifications; the update did not affect eligibility criteria for forest projects
-
v3.01 Sept 2009 (the issuer's date)source
Version 3.0 was a significant revision from Version 2.1 that involved a two-year process; expanded applicability so that the protocol may be used with projects throughout the United States; introduced the requirement for each project developer to sign a Project Implementation Agreement (PIA)
-
v2.16 Sept 2007 (the issuer's date)source
Version 2.1 was a policy revision with a full public comment period and Reserve Board approval.
-
v1.0source
The first forest protocol developed under the California Climate Action Registry.
Projects using CAR-US-FOREST
Browse 39 published projects using CAR-US-FOREST, listed alphabetically. There is no ranking for this methodology yet: it appears here automatically once 5 of its projects not in the pipeline or under validation are rated. Open a project to view its registry details and the analysis available for that project.
Which registries list projects under CAR-US-FOREST?
In CarbonMeld's data, CAR-US-FOREST projects are on 2 registries: Climate Action Reserve (37) and American Carbon Registry (2). Being listed on a registry is not the same as being registered: the «Registered» column counts the projects each registry shows as registered, and credits are issued only after each verification.
| Registry | Projects | Registered | Projects list |
|---|---|---|---|
| Climate Action Reserve (CAR) | 37 | 14 | See the list |
| American Carbon Registry (ACR) | 2 | 0 | See the list |
Counts of project records in CarbonMeld's data, with or without a CarbonMeld analysis. «Registered» counts the records whose current registry status is «registered», as last read (20 November 2026); projects in a later status, such as awaiting verification approval, late to verify or completed, are not in that column.
- Analysis: Rated
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Rated
- Analysis: Rated
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Too early to rate
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Not yet assessable
- Analysis: Rated
- Analysis: Rated
- Analysis: Rated
- Analysis: Not yet assessable
- Analysis: Too early to rate
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
- Analysis: Re-assessment pending
