Advanced Refrigeration - ARS2025001

Audit Analysis

A multi-site refrigeration retrofit project (grocery stores in four US states) with VVB-confirmed additionality and all 20 material findings corrected, but weakened by a project-specific baseline, a leakage treatment that is deemed negligible without quantification and contradicted by the validation report, and the absence of FNRB, usage-monitoring, and CORSIA/CCP data. The identical claimed, verified, and lifetime ERR figures are plausibly consistent with a one-time refrigerant replacement but require explicit confirmation.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Leakage is deemed negligible in the monitoring report but the validation report does not address leakage at all — the two documents contradict each other on a core integrity element
• ⚠All three ERR figures (claimed, verified, lifetime) are identical at 57,830 tCO₂e; while this may reflect a one-time refrigerant replacement, no document explicitly confirms the credit is a single-event rather than a continuous stream, leaving over-crediting risk unexcluded
• ⚠Twenty material findings (incorrect cooling capacities, wrong property names, inconsistent commissioning dates, missing agreements) indicate substantial data-quality issues in the underlying project documentation, all of which were corrected but collectively raise reliability concerns

Credit Vintages