Alize Camseki 20.8 MW Wind Farm Project, Turkey (300209)

Integrity

The project has a positive integrity signal because the verification report confirms additionality and the project uses a combined test under ACM0002. However, the baseline is project-specific and last reassessed in 2010, the leakage deduction is 0%, and the contradiction log shows earlier documents treated leakage as not addressed, which weakens confidence in the environmental claims.

Transparency

Transparency is moderate at best: the monitoring period is clearly stated and the VVB is named as Re Carbon Ltd., but the extracted record does not state the verified emission reduction total, the usage monitoring method, or FNRB values. The monitoring report also contains numerous internal errors and corrective actions, which suggests the reporting package is not fully clean.

Claim Safety

Claim safety is limited by missing quantitative safeguards around usage and FNRB, plus a project-specific baseline rather than a more standardized or recently reassessed baseline. The project is marked CORSIA-eligible, which does not by itself create a problem, but it means the claim should be treated cautiously because the record does not clearly rule out broader market-claim complexity.

Documentation

Documentation quality is weak because extraction confidence is low, one evidence document is not identified, and the monitoring report required many corrective actions and revisions. The record does show active verification and closure of several corrective actions, but the number of documentation issues and the missing/unclear fields reduce confidence in the completeness of the file.

Overall

I privileged the more recent monitoring-report evidence for the current period, but I also gave weight to the contradiction log because it shows unresolved reliability issues across documents. Specifically, I treated the VVB-confirmed combined additionality test as stronger than the older barrier-test reference, but I discounted the score because the record also shows contradictions on leakage treatment, reversal status, and the crediting period. The low extraction confidence and the many corrective actions further justify a conservative overall score.