GS1247 VPA 88 Southern Ethiopia Community Boreholes

Audit Analysis

This Gold Standard kitchen-stove project (VPA 88 under PoA GS1247) has VVB-confirmed additionality and no reversal events, but is undermined by a high volume of open corrective actions, a project-specific baseline, a 0% leakage deduction, and ten cross-document contradictions including a significant discrepancy in claimed ERR figures. The exact match between claimed and verified ERR for the monitoring period, combined with the project-name mismatch between the borehole title and the stove methodology, raises data-reliability concerns that temper confidence in the credit claims.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Project title reads 'Southern Ethiopia Community Boreholes' while the methodology (TPDDTEC) and all document content describe improved kitchen stoves — a fundamental identity mismatch that may indicate mis-extracted or misattributed documents.
• ⚠Ten cross-document contradictions identified, including claimed ERR of 2,266 (verification report, 2026) versus 4,403 (PDD, 2023), and leakage deduction of 0% (verification report) versus 5% (PDD).
• ⚠Twelve corrective actions remain open at the time of the verification report, including requirements to submit baseline survey results, elaborate the leakage analysis, and provide a detailed monitoring plan with carbon parameters.
• ⚠Five Further Assessment Requests (FARs) are outstanding, covering SDG indicator applicability, VPA-level fNRB reporting, and monitoring-option justifications.
• ⚠Leakage deduction is 0% in the most recent verification report despite the PDD originally specifying 5%; the justification shifts from 'deemed negligible' (2020 monitoring report) to 'quantified' (2026 verification report) without a clear quantitative bridge.

Credit Vintages