Panama Tropical Reforestation

Audit Analysis

This Gold Standard tropical reforestation project in Panama has a verified additionality test, a 20% buffer pool, and no reported reversals, but is burdened by ten open corrective actions concerning fundamental biomass and soil-carbon calculation methodology, multiple contradictions in ERR figures across documents, and a project-specific baseline with no stated reassessment date. The verified 79,027 tCO₂e for the 2024 monitoring period represents roughly 6× the linear pro-rata expectation from the 540,335 tCO₂e lifetime ex-ante estimate, a ratio that is difficult to reconcile without the calculation-methodology concerns raised in the CARs being fully resolved.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Ten corrective actions remain open, including justification of biomass stock calculation (diameter-only vs. allometric equation with height), SOC calculation with no monitoring parameter in the PDD, and appropriateness of the volume equation used for ex-post calculation
• ⚠Contradictions in ERR figures: the verification report states 79,027 tCO₂e verified while the monitoring report states 98,784 tCO₂e, and the claimed figure differs between 79,027 (VR) and 135,146 (MR)
• ⚠Leakage deduction of 0% justified only as 'deemed negligible' with no quantified analysis, while an appendix characterises leakage as 'quantified' — an unresolved inconsistency
• ⚠Stakeholder consultation non-compliance with the 30-day invitation period (Rule 3.4.2) was noted, with a deviation request approved to mitigate
• ⚠The reversal-events detail reads 'There is no reversal of GHG benefits…for non-forest projects,' which is boilerplate language inappropriate for an A/R project and does not substantively address forest carbon-stock reversal risk

Credit Vintages

Issuance data not yet available — check back soon.