VCH Red River Valley - Soil Carbon

Audit Analysis

The VCH Red River Valley soil carbon project is at validation stage with a 20% buffer pool and a combined additionality test, but suffers from a complete absence of leakage treatment, an unverified project-specific baseline, and three material findings flagging measurement-consistency risks in calcareous soils. No monitoring data, verified ERR figure, or FNRB methodology is available, leaving the 6,791 claimed ERR entirely uncorroborated. The project shows early-stage promise but significant gaps in both methodological rigor and data transparency.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Leakage is entirely unaddressed (no deduction, no justification) in a soil carbon project where supply-chain and land-use-change leakage pathways are well established
• ⚠Three material findings in the validation report flag risks of SOC/SIC confusion in calcareous soils and year-to-year measurement inconsistency, with four corrective actions still outstanding
• ⚠No verified ERR figure exists; the 6,791 claimed ERR is uncorroborated by any monitoring or verification data
• ⚠Carbon content was not independently tested and storage was not independently verified, weakening the physical basis of the credit claim

Credit Vintages

Issuance data not yet available — check back soon.