Grouped Reforestation Project by Cropzone Agro Forestry Private Limited

Audit Analysis

A VCS-registered reforestation project in India spanning four states with VVB-confirmed additionality and a 10% buffer pool, but undermined by a weak 0% leakage justification for a timber-producing project, a significant under-delivery relative to the pro-rata lifetime expectation (~46%), and nine corrective actions flagged in the verification report. The project is functional and registered but carries moderate risk of over-crediting and documentation gaps that reduce confidence in the claimed removals.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Leakage deduction of 0% justified only as 'deemed negligible' for a project explicitly producing harvestable Mahogany and Teak timber, with no quantified displacement analysis
• ⚠Verified removals of 22,708 tCO2e represent only ~46% of the pro-rata lifetime expectation (~49,400 tCO2e) for the 4.7-year monitoring period, indicating substantial under-delivery
• ⚠Nine corrective actions and five clarification items in the verification report (2023-09-12) reveal material documentation deficiencies including missing LTA calculations, land area discrepancies, and absent common-practice analysis
• ⚠ERR figures are inconsistent across documents: the PDD (2021) states a lifetime claim of 211,427 tCO2e while the validation report (2023) reports 25,231 tCO2e, and the verified figure is 22,708 tCO2e

Credit Vintages