Native Hydraid BioSand Water Filter Program Central America: NE – VPA – 02 – HON

Audit Analysis

A Gold Standard water-filter displacement project in Honduras with VVB-confirmed additionality and a conservative verification (the VVB reduced the monitoring report's claim by roughly 44%), but undermined by seven cross-document contradictions, a 0% leakage deduction with inconsistent justification, a project-specific baseline with no recorded reassessment, and a 100% usage rate that is contradicted by the monitoring report. The low extraction confidence and an 'unknown' document type further erode confidence in the evidentiary record.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Seven contradictions across key fields (ERR figures, usage rate, leakage justification, grievance mechanism, FNRB method, crediting period) indicate significant data-reliability problems between the monitoring report and verification report.
• ⚠Usage rate verified at 100% in the verification report but recorded as 1% in the monitoring report — a 100-fold discrepancy that, even if the 100% figure is correct, represents an aggressive assumption for a household water filter.
• ⚠Leakage deduction of 0% with contradictory justifications ('quantified' in the verification report vs 'deemed negligible' in the monitoring report) leaves the basis for the zero deduction unclear.
• ⚠Low extraction confidence and an 'unknown' document type in the evidence list reduce confidence that all material documents were properly reviewed.
• ⚠Multiple corrective actions remain open, including the absence of a grievance logbook on-site, missing random-selection evidence, and the need for an Objective Observer site visit in the next monitoring period.

Credit Vintages