Xinfeng AWMS GHG Mitigation Project in Liaoning province

Audit Analysis

The Xinfeng AWMS project in Liaoning is a registered VCS waste-methane avoidance project verified by Carbon Check (India), but the verification report identifies 17 material findings and 44 corrective actions spanning financial additionality, baseline data quality, document versioning, and monitoring completeness. The first monitoring period's verified ERR (103,290 tCO₂e) aligns closely with the pro-rata share of the PDD lifetime estimate, but the sheer volume of unresolved documentation gaps and methodological inconsistencies significantly undermines confidence in the project's robustness.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠17 material findings and 44 corrective actions identified in the verification report, including inconsistent GPS coordinates, outdated 9.5% financial benchmark from 2013, electricity consumption calculated at full capacity rather than measured, and a discrepancy in the MCFj value (60.8% vs 61.1%)
• ⚠Multiple critical-level (CL) findings flag missing ownership/carbon rights documents, missing SDG monitoring documentation, missing HR policy, and lack of double-counting clarification with China's national emissions trading scheme
• ⚠Outdated document versions referenced throughout (VCS Standard 4.4, Tool 05 v02, Tool 06 v03) when current versions are 4.7, 03.0, and 04.0 respectively
• ⚠FPIC (Free, Prior and Informed Consent) status not found in the extracted record

Credit Vintages