13.75 MW Grid connected Wind Electricity generation Project by Tamilnadu Newsprints and Papers Limited
Score Breakdown
Integrity
verified Additionality was confirmed by the VVB, Bureau Veritas Certification, using a combined test approach.
missing The validation report lists 23 corrective action requests and 25 clarification requests, and leakage treatment is not addressed.
Transparency
verified The project has a named VVB and a defined monitoring period from 2012-04-04 to 2014-01-13.
missing Verified versus claimed emission reduction totals are not stated, and key monitoring details such as leakage and usage monitoring are missing.
Claim Safety
verified The project uses ACM 0002 for a grid-connected wind activity, which is generally a lower-risk project type than many land-use categories.
missing The baseline is project-specific rather than a recently reassessed standardized baseline, and leakage justification is not addressed.
Documentation
verified The record includes a validation report, a named verifier, and a crediting period spanning 2012-04-04 to 2022-04-03.
missing Extraction confidence is only medium, and the available documents still leave several core fields unstated, including buffer pool, leakage deduction, and verified issuance totals.
Detailed Analysis
Integrity
The validation report from Bureau Veritas Certification confirms additionality through a combined test, which supports the project’s core environmental claim. At the same time, the report records 23 corrective action requests and 25 clarification requests, and the extracted record does not state any leakage treatment or buffer pool coverage, which weakens confidence in the robustness of the crediting setup.
Transparency
The project has a named verifier and a clearly stated monitoring period, which helps traceability. But the extracted documents do not state claimed or verified emission reduction totals, and key MRV elements such as leakage justification and usage monitoring method are missing, limiting transparency.
Claim Safety
Wind power under ACM 0002 is generally a comparatively conservative project type, and the VVB-confirmed additionality reduces over-crediting concern. Still, the baseline is project-specific rather than a recently reassessed standardized baseline, and leakage is not addressed, so claim safety remains only moderate.
Documentation
The record includes a validation report, a named VVB, and a defined crediting period, which is a solid documentary base. However, extraction confidence is only medium, and several important fields are not stated in the available documents, including buffer pool coverage, leakage deduction, and verified emission reduction totals.
Overall
Overall, the project looks moderately credible but not especially well documented. There are no contradictions listed in the extracted record, so no document hierarchy issue needs to be resolved; however, the absence of key MRV details and the large number of CARs/CLs in validation justify a cautious score.
Audit Analysis
This is a CDM wind project with VVB-confirmed additionality and a project-specific baseline, which supports moderate integrity. However, the record shows substantial validation issues, with 23 corrective action requests and 25 clarification requests, and key MRV details such as leakage treatment and verified issuance figures are not stated in the extracted documents.
Project Description
Status: Registered Type: PA Methodology: ACM2 Project type: Wind Sub-type: Wind Region: Asia & Pacific Sub-region: Southern Asia Reductions 1st period: 28.478 ktCO2e/yr
Red Flags
- The validation report records 23 corrective action requests and 25 clarification requests, indicating material documentation and design issues.
- Leakage treatment, buffer pool coverage, and verified emission reduction totals are not stated in the available record.
Credit Vintages
| Issued | Retired | Available | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 50,928 | 0 | 50,928 | |
| Total | 50,928 | 0 | 50,928 |
Cosa migliorerebbe questo punteggio
- Provide the monitoring verification figures, including claimed and verified emission reductions, along with the underlying calculation sheets.
- Document leakage treatment, buffer pool or reversal provisions, and a clearer safeguards package including grievance mechanism details.
Questi suggerimenti indicano quali prove pubbliche aggiuntive potrebbero migliorare il livello di confidenza di questa valutazione. Non garantiscono un punteggio futuro più alto.
Risk Indicators
VVB-confirmed additionality
No reversal treatment stated
Leakage not addressed
Project baseline, reassessment not stated
FPIC noted, grievance mechanism not stated
CORSIA/CCP status not stated
Where to buy
+ Know where to buy this?
Listing multiple projects? Send us a CSV at [email protected].
⚑ Dispute this rating
Sei il proprietario di questo progetto?
Correzione metadati (gratuita)
Nome, paese, marketplace o link errati? Segnalacelo.
Non modifica lo score.
[email protected] →Rivalutazione con nuovi documenti
Hai documentazione aggiornata non ancora inclusa? Puoi richiedere un nuovo run della pipeline con i nuovi input.
Invia Documenti →