Ningxia Xiangshan Wind Farm Project - CORSIA Eligible
Score Breakdown
Integrity
verified Additionality was confirmed by the VVB using an investment test, and the project uses ACM0002 with a project baseline.
missing The verification report lists two CARs, including an IRR value inconsistency and a monitoring plan not aligned with ACM0002; leakage justification is not addressed in the extracted record.
Transparency
verified A recent verification report dated 2024-12-27 and a monitoring period from 2022-09-01 to 2024-08-31 are available.
missing The extracted record does not provide verified or claimed ERR totals, and key monitoring details such as usage monitoring and grid emissions inputs are not stated.
Claim Safety
verified The project is an avoidance-type wind farm with a quantified leakage deduction of 0%, which is generally consistent with low leakage risk for this sector.
missing The record contains a leakage contradiction, and the project is marked not CORSIA-eligible, which reduces confidence in external claim safety.
Documentation
verified The record includes a substantial set of extracted documents, with 33 documents used and a named VVB.
missing Extraction confidence is only medium, and the verification report required corrective actions, indicating incomplete or imperfect documentation quality.
Detailed Analysis
Integrity
The project has a positive integrity signal because the VVB confirmed additionality through an investment test, and the baseline method is identified as project-based under ACM0002. That said, the verification report dated 2024-12-27 found two CARs: one on IRR consistency with the FSR and one because the monitoring plan was not aligned with ACM0002. Leakage is also weakly documented, with the extracted record showing no clear justification despite a 0% deduction.
Transparency
Transparency is moderate because the monitoring period is clearly stated and the verification report is recent. However, the extracted facts do not include verified or claimed ERR totals, and several operational details are not stated, including usage monitoring and grid emissions inputs. The documentation is therefore usable but incomplete for full public scrutiny.
Claim Safety
Claim safety is mixed. The project type is wind power, which usually has limited leakage concerns, and the record shows a 0% leakage deduction. However, the leakage justification is contradictory in the extracted data, and the project is marked not CORSIA-eligible, which limits the safety of broader market claims.
Documentation
Documentation quality is below average but not poor enough to be severely limiting. The record says 33 documents were used and identifies CCSC as the VVB, but extraction confidence is only medium. The presence of CARs and required corrective actions also suggests the documentation package was not fully clean or fully consistent.
Overall
Overall, this is a moderately credible renewable-energy crediting case, but the evidence is not strong enough for a high-confidence score. I privileged the 2024-12-27 verification report over the contradictory leakage note because it is the most recent and authoritative document in the extracted set, but the contradiction still lowers reliability. I also privileged the statement that benefit sharing is described, while noting the opposing extracted contradiction; both issues indicate some inconsistency in the record and justify a downward adjustment.
Audit Analysis
This is a registered wind project with VVB-verified additionality and a recent verification report, which supports moderate integrity. However, the record shows unresolved documentation issues, a leakage treatment contradiction, and no verified emissions-claim totals in the extracted facts, which limits confidence in the claimed climate benefit.
Project Description
Ningxia Xiangshan Wind farm Project (hereafter referred to as the Project) is located in Zhongwei City, Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, People’s Republic of China. The project owner is Ningxia Zhongwei Aluminum New Energy Co., Ltd. The project started construction on 01/11/2016 and starts commercial operation on 15/04/2017 and fully operation on 20/07/2017. The proposed project has a total installed capacity of 397.5MW consisting of 265 wind turbines with unit capacity of 1,500kW. The expected annual power delivered to the grid is 948,633.8 MWh. The power generated will be delivered to the Northwest Power Grid (NWPG) via Ningxia Power Grid. The scenario existing prior to the start of the implementation of the project activity is the same as the baseline scenario as identified in section 2.3, i.e. electricity would have otherwise been generated by the operation of power plants connected to NWPG and by the addition of new generation sources of NWPG. When the proposed project is put into operation, the power generated will substitute a part of power supply in NWPG which is dominated by fuel-fired power plants and thus reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emission through avoiding CO2 emissions produced by NWPG. The estimated annual average emission reduction is 727,982 tCO2e. The VCS crediting period of the Project is from 15/04/2017 to 14/04/2027, totally 10 years. The estimated emission reduction during this period is 7,279,820 tCO2e. The emission reduction during this monitoring period from 15/04/2017 to 28/02/2019 is 1,535,574 tCO2e. The proposed project will contribute to sustainable development mainly by: Reducing the emission of CO2 and other pollutants compared with fuel-fired power plant; Creating local employment opportunities during the construction (more than 200 people) and operation (200 people) of the proposed project and improving the living standard of local people; With the help of the road, which was constructed due to the proposed project, agricul
Red Flags
- The verification report identified two corrective action requests, including an IRR inconsistency and a monitoring plan not aligned with ACM0002.
- Leakage treatment is inconsistent across extracted records, and the project is marked CORSIA-ineligible in the available data.
Credit Vintages
| Issued | Retired | Available | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | 529,532 | 503,090 | 26,442 | |
| 2018 | 844,399 | 844,399 | 0 | |
| 2019 | 809,686 | 267,907 | 541,779 | |
| 2020 | 756,932 | 484,215 | 272,717 | |
| 2021 | 581,127 | 338,028 | 243,099 | |
| 2022 | 96,700 | 48,956 | 47,744 | |
| 2024 | 90,000 | 26,926 | 63,074 | |
| Total | 3,708,376 | 2,513,521 | 1,194,855 |
Cosa migliorerebbe questo punteggio
- Provide a fully reconciled monitoring package with the CARs closed, including the corrected IRR basis and an ACM0002-compliant monitoring plan.
- Publish verified ERR totals, leakage rationale, and a clear reconciliation of the contradictory leakage and benefit-sharing statements.
Questi suggerimenti indicano quali prove pubbliche aggiuntive potrebbero migliorare il livello di confidenza di questa valutazione. Non garantiscono un punteggio futuro più alto.
Risk Indicators
VVB-confirmed investment test
Avoidance project; non-permanence not applicable
0% deduction but justification inconsistent
Project baseline; reassessment timing limited
FPIC and grievance mechanism documented
CORSIA-ineligible; no CCP status stated
Where to buy
Marketplaces
+ Know where to buy this?
Listing multiple projects? Send us a CSV at [email protected].
⚑ Dispute this rating
Registry Documents
issuance
- VCS-Issuance-Representation-Single-Representor-v3.pdf
- Issuance-Representation-Single-PP-v4.3 1867.pdf
- VCS-Issuance-Representation-Single-Representor-v3.5 NINGXIA.pdf
- VCS-Issuance-Representation-Single-Representor-v4 1867.pdf
- VCS-Issuance-Representation-Single-Representor-v4.1 ningxia.pdf
- 1867-VCS-Issuance-Representation-Single-Representor-v4.1 1867.pdf
monitoring
Other
validation
- 0419_VCS Verification Representation, v3.3.pdf
- VCS-Verification-Representation-v4.1 - Ningxia Xiangshan Wind Farm Project-CTI.pdf
- VCS-Verification-Report-Ningxia Xiangshan Wind Farm Project-v4.0_CTI.pdf
- VCS-Verification-Report-Ningxia Xiangshan Wind Farm Project-v4.1-CTI.pdf
- A+SH_SYST_00419 Vcs Validation and Verification Report.pdf
- A+SH_SYST_00419 Vcs Validation and Verification Report.pdf
- +11 more
Sei il proprietario di questo progetto?
Correzione metadati (gratuita)
Nome, paese, marketplace o link errati? Segnalacelo.
Non modifica lo score.
[email protected] →Rivalutazione con nuovi documenti
Hai documentazione aggiornata non ancora inclusa? Puoi richiedere un nuovo run della pipeline con i nuovi input.
Invia Documenti →