Solar Grouped Project By Acme Group (Ekiesl-VCS-Aug-16-01)

Audit Analysis

A long-running Indian solar avoidance project (ACM0002 v17) with a jurisdictional grid baseline and VVB-confirmed additionality, but plagued by extensive documentation gaps, a methodological flaw in the common-practice analysis, and a low extraction confidence rating. The verified emissions reductions are broadly consistent with the ex-ante estimate on a pro-rata basis, but the volume of corrective actions and material findings across multiple monitoring periods raises concerns about the robustness of the MRV record.

Project Description

Red Flags

• ⚠Common-practice additionality analysis was initially conducted on combined capacity rather than individually for each large-scale component, contrary to CDM/VCS guidance for grouped projects (noted in the 2026 verification report material findings).
• ⚠The 2026 verification report does not explicitly address reversal/permanence risk, and no buffer pool percentage is stated in any available document.
• ⚠Minimum extraction confidence is rated low, indicating at least one key document was poorly readable, undermining confidence in the extracted data.
• ⚠Seven or more Corrective Action Requests were raised in the latest verification cycle, covering missing JMRs, calibration certificates, stakeholder consultation records, and double-counting undertakings.
• ⚠Benefit-sharing documentation was present in the 2023 verification report but is no longer described in the 2026 verification report, indicating a regression in social-safeguard reporting.

Credit Vintages